• Home
  • News
  • Top Picks
    • Movies & Films: Top 25
    • Documentaries: Top 25
    • Films For Students: Top 10
    • Music Videos: Top 10
  • Categories
    • Film
    • Documentary
    • Shorts
    • Blog
    • Calendar
    • Links
    • About

Miss Liberty's Film & Documentary World

Libertarian Movies, Films & Documentaries

Knickerbocker Holiday (1944)

Tagged: Anti-taxation, Corrupt government, Free press as hero

A corrupt city council and arrogant governor in early America are reformed by a newspaper editor with radical ideas of liberty. [ Knickerbocker Holiday credits: Dir: Harry Joe Brown/ Nelson Eddy, Charles Coburn, Constance Dowling/ 85 min/ Musical-Dance, Comedy/ Corrupt Government, American Revolution, Anti-Taxation]

“This light, upbeat comedy is likely to have a special appeal for fans of the movie musical genre.”

This film begins with the tongue-in-cheek proviso that any similarity between the city depicted and New York City is “purely coincidental.” In fact, the story is a parody of New York City politics, exaggerating corruption for comic purposes.

Among other misdeeds of the city council portrayed here: it wants to hang someone, anyone, simply to impress the new governor; it secretly engages in various forms of profitable trade that it has otherwise made illegal for ordinary people; and it wants to arrest the local newspaper editor for “thinking.” When the new governor arrives, there is hope for something better, but he turns out to be even more corrupt and grasping. Says he: “With regard to taxes, we shall have only those that are just … just as much as they can bear.”

The hero is the newspaper editor, who overcomes all this to incite a successful rebellion. Unfortunately, the rebellion turns into mob rule, convincing the hero that the governor is needed after all but just has to be held in check. It’s a little unsatisfying from a libertarian perspective to see such a quick reconciliation with the heretofore thieving governor, but in a way it’s consistent with the popular cynical attitude toward government: it’s predatory, but people (think they) need it.

Despite the serious political themes, Knickerbocker Holiday is first and foremost a light musical comedy, with many songs and jokes. Even the rebellion, when it comes, is musical. Nelson Eddy, in the leading role, does most of the singing. But the best tune is a comic duet between the governor and the head of the city council, about the “indispensable man,” that man being (from their perspective) someone who goes around buying political support at public expense. In the end, the film seems to back the status quo; however, most of the story has a strong anticorruption, antitax flavor. This light, upbeat comedy is likely to have a special appeal for fans of the movie musical genre.

External Reviews

“Producers Corp of America did not spare the budget in readying this adaptation of Knickerbocker Holiday from the original play by Maxwell Anderson and Kurt Weill. Harry Joe Brown, who produced and directed for the screen, has done much to emphasize the film’s humor, gaiety and songs in a fast-moving pic.”
–Variety

How to See It

YouTube Video Search
Online Video Search

Links

IMDB
Wikipedia

Share this:

  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email

Related

Featured Post

covid response

Covid Response Pitch Meeting: Harrison Hill Smith

This hilarious skit by Comedian Harrison Hill Smith reimagines the government's initial Covid response pitch meeting among experts. If you're wondering how authorities could have made their response so haphazard and contradictory, this is one scenario. h/t Instapundit … Continue Reading

Amazing Grace

Amazing Grace (2006)

WINNER: TOP 25 LIBERTARIAN FILMS Inspired by Christian teachings against slavery, William Wilberforce leads an arduous but ultimately victorious life-long battle to abolish the slave trade. [ Amazing Grace credits: Dir: Michael Apted/ Ioan Gruffudd, Benedict Cumberbatch, Albert Finney/ 111 min/ Drama, … Continue Reading

victimless crime spree

Derrick J’s Victimless Crime Spree (2012)

WINNER: TOP 25 LIBERTARIAN DOCUMENTARIES Libertarian activist Derrick J. Freeman chronicles his arrest and incarceration for five "crimes" -- videoing police, dancing in a public place, smoking cannabis, wearing a hat in court, and riding a bike -- in a civil disobedience spree that demonstrates just how … Continue Reading

Themes

Abuse of power American revolution Anti-draft Anti-regulation Anti-slavery Anti-socialism Anti-taxation Anti-war Ayn Rand Corrupt government Creator as hero Democide Econ 101 Eminent domain Equality & law Escape from socialism Freedom of speech Free press as hero Government as bigot Government as torturer Government enforced morality Government healthcare Government schools Incompetent government Individualism John Stossel Law & liberty Legalize Drugs Libertarian heroes Libertarianism 101 Power corrupts Power worship Pro-capitalism Pro-immigration Propaganda Psychiatric coercion Resistance to tyranny Right to secede Search & seizure Second amendment Sexual liberty Social tolerance Unions & monopolies Voluntarism Working for government

Genres/Categories

Action-Adventure Animated Biography Blog Comedy Documentary Drama Family Featured Film Foreign History Horror Music-Dance Netflix News Romance SciFi-Fantasy Shorts Thriller Upcoming Western

About Miss Liberty

This site is a collection of films and documentaries of particular interest to libertarians (and those interested in libertarianism). It began as a book, Miss Liberty’s Guide to Film: Movies for the Libertarian Millennium, where many of the recommended films were first reviewed. The current collection has grown to now more than double the number in that original list, and it’s growing still.

  • RSS

© 2025 Miss Liberty's Film & Documentary World. All Rights Reserved